5/16/01 114 DECLARATION of Emmett C. Stanton by defendants' ReplayTV
Inc, and Sonicblue Inc in opposition to ex parte
application for appointment of special discovery referee
[106-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/17/02] [2:01cv9358]
10/31/01 1 COMPLAINT filed Summons(es) issd referred to Discovery
Charles F. Eick (jag) [Entry date 11/02/01] [2:01cv9358]
10/31/01 2 NOTICE OF INTERESTED PARTIES filed by plaintiffs (jag)
[Entry date 11/02/01] [2:01cv9358]
10/31/01 -- REPORT ON THE FILING OF AN ACTION REGARDING COPYRIGHT (cc:
form mailed to Washington, D.C.)(Opening) (ir)
[Entry date 11/02/01] [2:01cv9358]
10/31/01 3 EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by plaintiffs to expedite
discovery; memo of PA in suppt thereof; Decl of Andrew M
White (ir) [Entry date 11/02/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/2/01 -- NOTICE OF FILING FEE DUE On Pro Hac Vice Application
mailed to attorney Peter B Rutledge for plaintiff CBS
Broadcasting Inc, Randolph Daniel Moss for plaintiff CBS
Broadcasting Inc, Thomas P Olson for plaintiff CBS
Broadcasting Inc (jag) [Entry date 11/02/01]
[2:01cv9358]
11/5/01 4 PRELIMINARY OPPOSITION by defendants to Plf's ex parte
application to expedite discovery [3-1] (ir)
[Entry date 11/05/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/13/01 -- LODGED APPL OF NON-RESIDENT Atty Thomas P Olson to appear
in a specific case submitted by plaintiffs (FWD TO CRD) (ir)
[Entry date 11/14/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/13/01 -- LODGED Appl of Non-Resident Atty Randolph D Moss to appear
in a specific case submitted by plaintiff (FWD TO CRD) (ir)
[Entry date 11/14/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/13/01 -- LODGED Appl of Non-Resident Atty Peter B Rutledge to Appear
in a specific case submitted by plaintiff (FWD TO CRD) (ir)
[Entry date 11/14/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/13/01 -- RESPONSE by Pro Hac Vice Attorneys Thomas P Olson, Randolph
Daniel Moss, Peter B Rutledge for plaintiff CBS
Broadcasting Inc; PHV fee: Paid (ir) [Entry date 11/19/01]
[2:01cv9358]
11/14/01 5 ORDER to reassign cs due to self-recusal by Judge Christina
A. Snyder Case reassigned from Judge Christina A. Snyder
to Judge Florence-Marie Cooper for all further
proceedingsCase now reads as CV 01-9358 FMC (Ex) (rn)
[Entry date 11/14/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/19/01 12 RETURN OF SUMMONS AND PROOF OF SERVICE executed upon
defendant ReplayTV Inc; Service by CCCP on 11/1/01 by
personally serving S/C to David Gershon, general counsel,
authorized to receive service of process. (bp)
[Entry date 11/27/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/19/01 12 RETURN OF SUMMONS AND PROOF OF SERVICE executed upon
defendant Sonicblue Inc; Service by CCCP on 11/1/01 by
personally serving S/C to David Gershon, General Counsel,
authorized to receive service of process. (bp)
[Entry date 11/27/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/20/01 6 MINUTES: This action has been reassigned to the Honorable
Florence-Marie Cooper. Please substitute the initials FMC
in place of the initials CAS by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper
CR: N/A (bp) [Entry date 11/20/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/20/01 7 APPLICATION AND ORDER of Non-Resident Attorney to Appear in
a Specific Case filed for plaintiffs Paramount Pict Corp,
Disney Enterprises, Natl Broadcasting, NBC Studios Inc,
Showtime Network Inc, United Paramount, ABC Inc, Viacom
Intl Inc, CBS Worldwide Inc, CBS Broadcasting Inc by Thomas
P Olson. Designating Jonathan H Anschell as local counsel.
Approved by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper. (Fee pd) (SEND) (ir)
[Entry date 11/20/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/20/01 8 APPLICATION AND ORDER of Non-Resident Attorney to Appear in
a Specific Case filed for plaintiffs Paramount Pict Corp,
Disney Enterprises, Natl Broadcasting, NBC Studios Inc,
Showtime Network Inc, United Paramount, ABC Inc, Viacom
Intl Inc, CBS Worldwide Inc, CBS Broadcasting Inc by Peter
B Rutledge. Designating Jonathan H Anschell as local
counsel. Approved by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper. (Fee pd)
(SEND) (ir) [Entry date 11/20/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/20/01 9 APPLICATION AND ORDER of Non-Resident Attorney to Appear in
a Specific Case filed for plaintiffs Paramount Pict Corp,
Disney Enterprises, Natl Broadcasting, NBC Studios Inc,
Showtime Network Inc, United Paramount, ABC Inc, Viacom
Intl Inc, CBS Worldwide Inc, CBS Broadcasting Inc by
Randolph Daniel Moss. Designating Jonathan H Anschell as
local counsel. Approved by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper.
(Fee pd) (SEND) (ir) [Entry date 11/20/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/21/01 10 MINUTES: At the parties request, the court sets a status
conference set for 3:00 12/13/01 by Judge Florence-Marie
Cooper CR: N/A (bp) [Entry date 11/26/01] [2:01cv9358]
11/21/01 11 AMENDED COMPLAINT [1-1] by plaintiffs' Paramount Pict Corp,
Disney Enterprises, Natl Broadcasting, NBC Studios Inc,
Showtime Network Inc, United Paramount, ABC Inc, Viacom
Intl Inc, CBS Worldwide Inc, and CBS Broadcasting Inc
Summons not issued (bp) [Entry date 11/26/01]
[2:01cv9358]
12/11/01 14 JOINT RULE 26 DISCOVERY PLAN filed; est length of trial 2-7
weeks (bp) [Entry date 12/12/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/12/01 13 SEPARATE STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT of facts by defendant
ReplayTV Inc, defendant Sonicblue Inc (bp)
[Entry date 12/12/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/12/01 15 SEPARATE STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT by plaintiff (bp)
[Entry date 12/13/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/13/01 17 MINUTES: Status conference; Crt ORD the transfer of case
CV01-10221 from Judge Dickran Tevrizian to Judge
Florence-Marie Cooper; Crt hears ptys on iss of
consolidation; Crt ORD Cases consolidated 2:01-cv-9358 with
member cases 2:01-cv-9693, 2:01-cv-9801, 2:01-cv-10221 for
all purposes & for trial; For ease of record keeping, Crt
Ord that all fur doc(s) & proceedings under Case No
CV01-9358, CV01-9693, CV01-9801 & CV01-10221 be closed; Crt
fur ORD the transfer of Mag Judge for discovery in
CV01-10221 from Mag Olguin to Mag Judge Charles Eick; Case
No will now read: CV01-10221 FMC (Ex); Crt DENIES Dfts' req
that Plfs be req to file a single Conslidated Cmp in the new
action; Crt finds that it is unnecessary to appt lead cnsl
to rep the plfs; Ptys advise Crt that they will work
together to file joint briefs whenever possible; Crt
indicated that iss of expert wit designation is premature;
Crt sets 1/15/02 as a deadline for Plf to disclose names of
employee wit they expect to call for trial as to issues that
have been identified; Crt also set the following sched;
discovery ddl set on 5/31/02; mot cut-off 7/1/02;
Pretrial Conference set for 9:00 8/20/02; Status conference
set for 3:00 2/13/02; Trial set on 9:00 8/20/02; Cnsl
are directed to file all fur doc(s) under Case No CV01-9358
FMC(Ex) only (See doc for fur details) by Judge
Florence-Marie Cooper CR: Pat Cuneo (PSEND) (ir)
[Entry date 12/19/01] [Edit date 12/19/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/14/01 25 ORDER for court trial by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper
discovery ddl set on 5/31/02; Final Pretrial Conference
set for 9:30 7/29/02; trial set on 8:00 8/20/02 (bp)
[Entry date 01/07/02] [2:01cv9358]
12/18/01 16 RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following
date(s): 12/13/01 CR: Pat Cuneo. (wdc) [Entry date 12/19/01]
[2:01cv9358]
12/18/01 -- TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 12/13/01. (wdc)
[Entry date 12/19/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/20/01 18 ANSWER filed by defendants ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc to
amended complaint [11-1]; jury demand (jp)
[Entry date 12/20/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/20/01 19 CERTIFICATION AS TO INTERESTED PARTIES filed by defendants
ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc (jp) [Entry date 12/20/01]
[2:01cv9358]
12/20/01 21 ANSWER to amended complaint [11-1] and COUNTERCLAIM by
defendant ReplayTV Inc, cntdft Sonicblue Inc; cntdft Turner
Broadcasting, Time Warner Inc.; jury demand; summons not
issued (bp) [Entry date 12/27/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/20/01 22 ANSWER filed by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant Sonicblue
Inc to amended complaint [11-1]; jury demand (bp)
[Entry date 12/27/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/20/01 23 ANSWER filed by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant Sonicblue
Inc to amended complaint [11-1]; jury demand (bp)
[Entry date 12/27/01] [2:01cv9358]
12/20/01 24 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant
Sonicblue Inc on 12/19/01 of answer to complaint (bp)
[Entry date 12/27/01] [2:01cv9358]
1/11/02 26 STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper
extending time to move to str jury demand to 6/7/02 (rrey)
[Entry date 01/14/02] [2:01cv9358]
1/11/02 27 NOTICE OF ERRATA by plfs Paramount Pict Corp, Disney
Enterprises, Natl Broadcasting, NBC Studios Inc, Showtime
Network Inc, United Paramount, ABC Inc, Viacom Intl Inc,
CBS Worldwide Inc, CBS Broadcasting Inc correcting amended
complaint [11-1] filed on 11/21/01. (nhac)
[Entry date 01/14/02] [2:01cv9358]
1/11/02 28 REPLY TO dft ReplayTV Inc's counterclaim [21-2] by plfs,
counter-defendants Time Warner Inc & Turner Broadcasting
System Inc. (nhac) [Entry date 01/14/02] [2:01cv9358]
1/14/02 -- NOTICE OF FILING FEE DUE On Pro Hac Vice Application mailed
to attorney Ronald L Klain w/the law firm of O'Molveny &
Myers LLp for plfs, counter-defendants Time Warner Inc &
Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. (nhac)
[Entry date 01/14/02] [2:01cv9358]
1/29/02 29 NOTICE by plaintiffs of hearing status conference formerly
sched for 2/13/02 cont to 2:30 2/22/02 (ir)
[Entry date 01/30/02] [2:01cv9358]
2/1/02 30 AMENDED proof of service re: notice of status conference.
(bp) [Entry date 02/05/02] [2:01cv9358]
2/11/02 -- LODGED ORDER submitted by plaintiff Paramount Pict Corp re
application of non-resident atty Ronald A Klain to appear
in a specific case (FWD TO CRD); Fee paid. (nhac)
[Entry date 02/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
2/12/02 31 APPLICATION AND ORDER of Non-Resident Attorney, Ronald A.
Klain to Appear in a Specific Case filed for plaintiffs'
Paramount Pict Corp, Disney Enterprises, Natl Broadcasting,
NBC Studios Inc, Showtime Network Inc, United Paramount,
ABC Inc, Viacom Intl Inc, CBS Worldwide Inc, CBS
Broadcasting Inc by Ronald A Klain. Designating attorney
Robert Schwartz as local counsel. Approved by Judge
Florence-Marie Cooper . (Fee pd) (bp) [Entry date 02/13/02]
[2:01cv9358]
2/20/02 32 STATUS REPORT by plaintiffs (nhac) [Entry date 02/21/02]
[2:01cv9358]
2/21/02 33 SECOND STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT by defendants ReplayTV
Inc, Sonicblue Inc (jp) [Entry date 02/22/02]
[2:01cv9358]
2/22/02 34 MINUTES: The Status Confernece is held. The court sets the
following briefing schedule: March 18, 2002, defense brief;
April 8, 2002 plaintiff's brief; April 15, 2002 defense
response. The court sets a further status conference set
for 2:30 4/18/02 by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper CR: Pat
Cuneo (bp) [Entry date 02/25/02] [2:01cv9358]
2/22/02 35 SUPPLEMENTAL STATUS REPORT by plaintiffs' (bp)
[Entry date 02/26/02] [2:01cv9358]
2/27/02 36 RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following
date(s): 2/22/02 (Re: ) CR: Pat Cuneo (pjap)
[Entry date 03/01/02] [2:01cv9358]
2/27/02 -- TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 2/22/02 (pjap)
[Entry date 03/01/02] [2:01cv9358]
3/18/02 37 BRIEF in support of jury trial as to all claims and parties
by defendant ReplayTV Inc (bp) [Entry date 03/19/02]
[2:01cv9358]
3/19/02 38 NOTICE OF ERRATA by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant
Sonicblue Inc correcting brief [37-1] (bp)
[Entry date 03/20/02] [2:01cv9358]
3/19/02 39 NOTICE of filing corrected amended complaint by plaintiff
(bp) [Entry date 03/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
3/19/02 40 CORRECTED AMENDED COMPLAINT [11-1] by plaintiffs' Paramount
Pict Corp, Disney Enterprises, Natl Broadcasting, NBC
Studios Inc, Showtime Network Inc, United Paramount, ABC
Inc, Viacom Intl Inc, CBS Worldwide Inc, CBS Broadcasting
Inc terminating Tristar Television, Columbia Tristar TV,
Columbia Pictures Te, Columbia Pictures, Fox Broadcasting
Co, Universal City Studi, Twentieth Century, Orion Pictures
Corp, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, WB Television Netwk, Castle Rock
Entertai, New Line Cinema Corp, Turner Broadcasting, Time
Warner Inc, Warner Bros TV Prod, Warner Bros, Home Box
Office, Time Warner Ent . Summons not issued (bp)
[Entry date 03/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
3/20/02 41 NOTICE OF DISCREPANCY AND ORDER by Judge Florence-Marie
Cooper ordering corrected amended complaint submitted by
plaintiff received on 3/19/02 to be fld and processed; fld
date to be the date the doc was stamped "received but not
fld" w/the Clerk (bp) [Entry date 03/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/1/02 47 STIPULATION and ORDER that the discovery motions will be
heard by special setting on Tuesday, April 23, 2002, at
9:00 a.m. unles the court otherwise orders. The joint
stipulation on the first motion shall be filed as soon as
possible but, in any event, no later than Tuesday, April 2,
2002 by Discovery Charles F. Eick (bp) [Entry date 04/09/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/2/02 42 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendants ReplayTV Inc,
Sonicblue Inc to compel discovery; motion hearing set for
9:00 4/26/02 (jp) [Entry date 04/03/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/2/02 43 JOINT STIPULATION by defendants ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc
for defendants motion to compel discovery [42-1] (jp)
[Entry date 04/03/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/2/02 44 ATTACHMENT A TO JOINT STIPULATION by defendants ReplayTV
Inc, Sonicblue Inc for dfts motion to compel discovery
[42-1] (jp) [Entry date 04/03/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/2/02 45 ATTACHMENT B TO JOINT STIPULATION by defendants ReplayTV
Inc, Sonicblue Inc for dfts motion to compel discovery
[42-1] (jp) [Entry date 04/03/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/2/02 46 ATTACHMENT C TO JOINT STIPULATION by defendants ReplayTV
Inc, Sonicblue Inc for dfts motion to compel discovery
[42-1] (jp) [Entry date 04/03/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/3/02 49 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant ReplayTV Inc,
defendant Sonicblue Inc to compel motion hearing set for
9:00 4/23/02 (bp) [Entry date 04/09/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/3/02 50 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff for protective
order motion hearing set for 9:00 4/23/02 (bp)
[Entry date 04/09/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/3/02 51 Joint Stipulation by plaintiff to motion for protective
order [50-1], motion to compel [49-1] (bp)
[Entry date 04/09/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/5/02 48 NOTICE of advancement of hearing on the motion to compel
discovery [42-1] 9:00 4/23/02 (bp) [Entry date 04/09/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/5/02 70 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff to compel;
motion hearing set for 9:00 4/23/02 (jp)
[Entry date 04/19/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/5/02 71 JOINT STIPULATION for plaintiffs motion to compel [70-1] (jp)
[Entry date 04/19/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/8/02 54 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant ReplayTV Inc on 4/2/02 of
motion to compel discovery. (bp) [Entry date 04/10/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/9/02 52 BRIEF by plaintiffs in opposition to dfts demand for jury
trial as to all claims & parties. (jp) [Entry date 04/09/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/9/02 53 DECLARATION of MARK A. SNYDER by plaintiffs in suppt of
plfs brief in opposition to dfts demand for jury trial as
to all claims and parties [52-1] (jp) [Entry date 04/09/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/9/02 55 REPLY by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant Sonicblue Inc
RE: Fist joint stip for plfs motion for protective order
[50-1], and motion to compel [49-1] (tw)
[Entry date 04/11/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/9/02 56 REPLY by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant Sonicblue Inc RE
second joint stip for dfts' motion to compel [49-1] (tw)
[Entry date 04/11/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/9/02 57 Suppl Memo of Law OPPOSITION by plaintiff to dfts motion
to compel discov [49-1] (tw) [Entry date 04/11/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/9/02 58 Suppl MEMORANDUM of law IN SUPPORT by plaintiffs of motion
for protective order [50-1], & in opp to dfts cross motion
to compel [49-1] (tw) [Entry date 04/11/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/9/02 59 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiffs Time Warner Ent,
Home Box Office, Warner Bros, Turner Broadcasting System
Inc, New Line Cinema Corp, Columbia Pictures Industries
Inc, TriStar Television, etc to strike dfts decls
submitted in connection with discov mots; Motion hearing
set for 9:00 4/23/02 (tw) [Entry date 04/11/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/11/02 60 REPLY by defendants ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc re "Third"
Joint Stipulation for plfs' motion to compel (nhac)
[Entry date 04/12/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/11/02 61 SUPPLEMETNAL MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT by plaintiffs in
suppt of their motion to compel [42-1] (nhac)
[Entry date 04/12/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/12/02 62 MINUTES before Judge Florence-Marie Cooper: Telephonic
Status Conf is held. The ptys & Crt discuss the upcoming
demonstration of the equipment which is the subject of this
lawsuit. The Crt resolves the various issues raised by cnsl
concerning the scope of the demonstration & confirms that
it will be conducted 04/18/02 @ 2:30 pm at the New Otani
Hotel. Magistrate Judge Eick will also attend. CR: Pat
Cuneo (jp) [Entry date 04/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/15/02 63 REPLY BRIEF by dfts ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc in suppt of
J/T as to all claims & ptys [52-1] (nhac)
[Entry date 04/16/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/15/02 64 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendants Replay TV Inc & Sonicblue
Inc on 4/15/02 of Reply Brief in Suppt of J/T as to all
claims & parties (nhac) [Entry date 04/16/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/16/02 65 THIRD STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT by defendants ReplayTV
Inc, Sonicblue Inc (jp) [Entry date 04/16/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/16/02 66 OPPOSITION by defendants ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc to
motion to strike [59-1] (jp) [Entry date 04/17/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/16/02 69 PROOF OF SERVICE BY MAIL by defendants ReplayTV Inc,
Sonicblue Inc on 4/16/02 of Oppostion to motion to strike
(jp) [Entry date 04/19/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/17/02 67 MINUTES: Setting of telephonic status conf. The crt gr ptys
req for a further status conf. Plf cnsl shall initiate the
call to chambers; Status conference held; Telephone
conference set on 2:00 4/26/02 by Judge Florence-Marie
Cooper CR: n/a (tw) [Entry date 04/18/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/18/02 68 RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following
date(s): 4/12/02 (Re: ) CR: Pat Cuneo (pjap)
[Entry date 04/19/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/18/02 -- TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 4/12/02 (pjap)
[Entry date 04/19/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/18/02 72 REPLY MEMORANDUM IN POINTS & AUTH by plaintiffs in suppt of
plfs motion to strike dfts decls submitted in connection
with discov mots [59-1] (jp) [Entry date 04/19/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/18/02 73 MINUTES: OFF SITE TECHNOLOGY DEMONSTRATION. The
demonstration is held at the New Otani Hotel. by Judge
Florence-Marie Cooper CR: Pat Cuneo (tw)
[Entry date 04/22/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/18/02 75 MINUTES: The court will defer ruling on the question of
whether and to what extent defendants are entitled to a
trial by jury until after it has considered the parties'
anticipated motions for summary judgment by Judge
Florence-Marie Cooper CR: N/A (bp) [Entry date 04/25/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/23/02 74 MINUTES: denying motion to strike dfts decls submitted in
connection with discov mots [59-1], that the motion to
compel [70-1] is taken under submission, that the motion
for protective order [50-1] is taken under submission, that
the motion to compel is taken under submission, that the
motion to compel discovery [42-1] is taken under submission
by Discovery Charles F. Eick CR: tape #02-17, 02-18 & 02-19
(bp) [Entry date 04/25/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/24/02 76 STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT by plaintiffs' (bp)
[Entry date 04/25/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/24/02 80 RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following
date(s): 4/18/02 (Re:) CR: Pat Cuneo (weap)
[Entry date 04/29/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/24/02 -- TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 4/18/02 (weap)
[Entry date 04/29/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/25/02 81 SUPPLEMENTAL STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT by defendants'
ReplayTV Inc, and Sonicblue Inc (bp) [Entry date 04/29/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/26/02 77 MINUTES: Except as expressly stated herein, the motion to
compel is denied, except: (a) the court expects that,
within thirty (30) days of the date of this order,
defendants will fulfill all of their prior promises to
provide discovery pertaining to the subject matter of the
motion; and (b) to the extent the motion is denied as to
portions of document requests No. 17, document request
No.31, and paramount interrogatory No.16, such denial is
without prejudice [70-1]. Any party seeking review of this
order shall cause the preparation and filing of a
transcript of the April 23, 2002 hearing by Discovery
Charles F. Eick CR: N/A (bp) [Entry date 04/29/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/26/02 78 MINUTES: denying motion for protective order [50-1],
except as expressly stated herein, defendants' cross-motion
to compel is denied. However, the court expects that,
within the same time frame established by this corder,
plaintiffs will fulfill all of their prior promises to
provide discovery pertaining to the subject matter of
defendants' cross-motion. Except as reflected by the
partial denial of defendants' cross-motion, plaintiffs
motion is denied [49-1]. Any party seeking review of this
order shall cause the preparation and filing of a
transcript of the April 23, 2002 hearing by Discovery
Charles F. Eick CR: N/A (bp) [Entry date 04/29/02]
[2:01cv9358]
4/26/02 79 MINUTES: Except as expressly stated herein, the motion to
compel discovery is denied. However, the coujrt expects
that, within the same time frame established by this order,
plaintiffs will fulfill all of their prior promises to
provide discovery pertaining to the subject matter of the
motion [42-1]. Any party seeking review of this order shall
cause the preparation and filing of a transcript of the
April 23, 2002 hearing by Discovery Charles F. Eick CR: N/A
(bp) [Entry date 04/29/02] [2:01cv9358]
4/26/02 82 MINUTES: telephone conference held; discovery ddl set on
6/30/02; Deposition to be completed by 08/31/02, Expert
discovery exchange completed by 10/25/02; Skummary Judgment
Motions: Motion filing 11/4/02, Opposition 11/25/02, Reply
12/9/02, Hearing 12/23/02 at 10:00, The matter will be set
for pretrial conference and trial following the Court's
ruling on the parties' Summary Judgment Motions. All
earlier scheduled dates & deadlines are hereby VACATED; by
Judge Florence-Marie Cooper; CR: Pat Cuneo (pc)
[Entry date 04/30/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/3/02 84 RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following
date(s): 4/26/02 CR: Pat Cuneo (dl) [Entry date 05/08/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/3/02 -- TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 4/26/02 (dl)
[Entry date 05/08/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/6/02 83 MINUTES: The court having received a telephonic request
from Laurence Pulgram that the court's minute order of
April 26, 2002 be amended, hereby grants counsel's request.
The minute order of April 26, 2002 is amended as follows:
Expert and fact discovery exchange completed by: October
25, 2002 by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper CR: N/A (bp)
[Entry date 05/07/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/9/02 85 MINUTES: Amended Civil Minutes of December 13, 2001. All
plaintiffs and counsel in case numbers 01-9693, 01-9801 and
01-10221 are ordered added to the docket under the
remaining case number: CV01-9358 FMC (Ex) by Judge
Florence-Marie Cooper CR: N/A (bp) [Entry date 05/10/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/10/02 86 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff for review, for
reconsideration of Magistrate Judge's discovery orders
motion hearing set for 10:00 6/3/02. Lodged proposed order
(bp) [Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/10/02 87 DECLARATION of David C. Vigilante by plaintiffs' in support
of motion for review [86-1], motion for reconsideration of
Judge's discovery orders [86-2] (bp) [Entry date 05/13/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/10/02 88 DECLARATION of Frederick A. F. Cooke, Jr. by plaintiffs' in
support of motion for review [86-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/10/02 89 DECLARATION of Richard A. Frankie by plaintiffs' Paramount
Pict Corp. et al in support of motion for review [86-1],
motion for reconsideration of Magistrate Judge's discovery
orders [86-2] (bp) [Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/10/02 91 DECLARATION of Michele Stratton, Del Mayberry, Jane Waxman,
Steve Rath and Michael Doodan by plaintiffs' in support of
motion for review [86-1], motion for reconsideration
Magistrate Judge's discovery orders [86-2] (bp)
[Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/10/02 92 DECLARATION of Robert H. Rotstein by plaintiffs' in support
of motion for review [86-1], motion for reconsideration of
Magistrate Judge's discovery orders [86-2] (bp)
[Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/10/02 96 EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by defendant ReplayTV Inc,
defendant Sonicblue Inc for a stay of Magistrate Judge
Eick's 04/26 Ord compelling dfts to Redesign their Product
to Electronically Create & Collect User information;
Lodged propsd Ord & ntc of mot/mot for review w/suppt docs.
(jp) [Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/10/02 97 MEMORANDUM OF POINTS & AUTH by defendants ReplayTV Inc,
Sonicblue Inc in suppt of ex parte application for a stay
of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26 Ord compelling dfts to
Redesign their Product to Electronically Create & Collect
User information [96-1] (jp) [Entry date 05/13/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/13/02 90 DECLARATION of Mike Cruz by plaintiffs' in support motion
for review [86-1], motion for reconsideration of Magistrate
Judge's discovery orders [86-2] (bp) [Entry date 05/13/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/13/02 93 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendants ReplayTV Inc,
Sonicblue Inc for review of Magistrate Judge Eick's
04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to compel
responses to docum requests 35 & 44; motion hearing set
for 10:00 6/3/02 (jp) [Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/13/02 94 MEMORANDUM OF POINTS & AUTH by defendants ReplayTV Inc,
Sonicblue Inc in suppt of motion for review of Magistrate
Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to
compel responses to docum requests 35 & 44 [93-1] (jp)
[Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/13/02 95 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendants ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc
on 5/10/02 of Ntc of mot & mot for review of Mag Judge
Eick's 04/26/02 Discov ord re dfts cross-mot to compel resp
to doc requests 35 & 44; Mem of PA in suppt. (jp)
[Entry date 05/13/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/13/02 98 AMENDED NOTICE of motion for review of Magistrate Judge
Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to compel
responses to docum requests 35 & 44 [93-1] filed by
defendants ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc (jp)
[Entry date 05/14/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/13/02 99 AMENDED NOTICE of motion and motion for review of
Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26 Ord compelling dfts to
Redesign their Product to Electronically Create & Collect
User information [96-1] filed by defendants ReplayTV Inc,
Sonicblue Inc (jp) [Entry date 05/14/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/13/02 100 CORRETED DECLARATION of EMMETT C. STANTON by defendants
ReplayTV Inc, Sonicblue Inc in suppt of two (2) motions for
review of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02 [93-1], [96-1]
(jp) [Entry date 05/14/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 101 ORDER by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper, granting ex parte
application for a stay of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26 Ord
compelling dfts to Redesign their Product to Electronically
Create & Collect User information [96-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 102 NOTICE OF DISCREPANCY AND ORDER by Judge Florence-Marie
Cooper ordering application to file brief submitted
received on 5/13/02 is not to be fld but instead rejected;
(bp) [Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 103 NOTICE OF ERRATA re: plaintiffs' ex parte application for a
stay of certain portions of April 26, 2002 discovery order
by plaintiff Columbia Pictures correcting (bp)
[Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 104 EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by Consumer Electonics
Association, Information Technology Associations for leave
to file amici curiae brief in support of defendants'
objections to Magistrate Judge's order Lodged proposed
order & brief (bp) [Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 105 PROOF OF SERVICE on 5/13/02 of application to file brief of
amici curiae civil liberties and consumer groups. (bp)
[Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 106 EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by plaintiff for appointment of
special discovery referee Lodged proposed order (bp)
[Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 107 DECLARATION of Scott P. Cooper by plaintiff Paramount Pict
Corp in support of ex parte application for appointment of
special discovery referee [106-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/15/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 108 RESPONSE by plaintiff Paramount Pict Corp to motion for
review of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re:
dfts cross-motion to compel responses to docum requests 35
& 44 [93-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 109 OPPOSITION by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant Sonicblue
Inc to ex parte application for a stay of Magistrate Judge
Eick's 04/26 Ord compelling dfts to Redesign their Product
to Electronically Create & Collect User information [96-1]
(bp) [Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 110 DECLARATION of Emmett C. Stanton by defendant ReplayTV Inc,
defendant Sonicblue Inc in opposition to ex parte
application for a stay of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26 Ord
compelling dfts to Redesign their Product to Electronically
Create & Collect User information [96-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/15/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 111 APPLICATION & ORDER granting plaintiff's ex parte
application for a stay of certain portions of April 26,
2002 discovery order to permit resolution of appeal to the
court by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper (bp)
[Entry date 05/16/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 112 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant ReplayTV Inc on 5/14/02 of
defendant's opposition to plaintiffs' ex parte application.
(bp) [Entry date 05/16/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/14/02 113 PROOF OF SERVICE on 5/13/02 of application to file brief of
amici curiae. (bp) [Entry date 05/16/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/16/02 115 OPPOSITION by defendants' ReplayTV Inc, and Sonicblue Inc
to ex parte application for appointment of special
discovery referee [106-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/17/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/16/02 116 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendants' ReplayTV Inc, and Sonicblue
Inc on 5/16/02 of defendant's opposition to ex application
for a special master. (bp) [Entry date 05/17/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 117 ORDER by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper, granting ex parte
application for leave to file amici curiae brief in support
of defendants' objections to Magistrate Judge's order
[104-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 118 BRIEF of Technology Industry Amici Curiae in support of
defendants' objections to Magistrate Judge's discovery
order (bp) [Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 119 ORDER by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper, denying ex parte
application for appointment of special discovery referee
[106-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 120 MEMORANDUM filed by plaintiff in opposition to motion for
review of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re:
dfts cross-motion to compel responses to docum requests 35
& 44 [93-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 121 DECLARATION of Simon Block by plaintiff in opposition to
motion for review of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02
discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to compel responses to
docum requests 35 44 [93-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/21/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 122 DECLARATION of Craig O. Thomas by plaintiff in opposition
to motion for review of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02
discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to compel responses to
docum requests 35 44 [93-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/21/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 123 DECLARATION of Emmett C. Stanton by defendant ReplayTV Inc,
defendant Sonicblue Inc in opposition to motion for review
of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts
cross-motion to compel responses to docum requests 35 & 44
[93-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 124 OPPOSITION by defendant to motion for review of Magistrate
Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to
compel responses to docum requests 35 & 44 [93-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 125 OBJECTIONS filed by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant
Sonicblue Inc to motion for review of Magistrate Judge
Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to compel
responses to docum requests 35 & 44 [93-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 126 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant
Sonicblue Inc on 5/20/02 of defendant's opposition to
plaintiffs motion for review and reconsideration of
Magistrate Judge's discovery orders. (bp)
[Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 127 OPPOSITION by plaintiff to motion for review of Magistrate
Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to
compel responses to docum requests 35 & 44 [93-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/21/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/20/02 -- PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED; proposed order granting
plaintiffs ex parte application for appointment of special
discovery referee. (bp) [Entry date 05/21/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/21/02 129 AMICI CURIAE BRIEF FILED by Electronic Privacy Information
Center, Electronic Frontier Foundation, Media Access
Project, Public Knowledge, The Privacy Foundation, Center
for Digital Democracy, Computer Professionals for Social
Responsibility, and Consumer Action in support of
defendants' objections to Magistrate Judge's discovery
order. (bp) [Entry date 05/23/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/21/02 130 APPLICATION filed by movant Electronic Privacy, Electronic
Frontier, Media Access Project, Public Knowledge, privacy
Foundation, Center for Digital Democracy, Computer
Professionals for Social Responsibility, Consumer Action
to file brief of Amci Curiae Civil Liberties & Consumer
Groups in suppt of dfts objections to Magistrate Judge's
discovery Order; Lodged Order & Brief (jp)
[Entry date 05/24/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/22/02 128 ORDER granting leave to file brief of amici curiae civil
liberties and Consumer Groups in support of defendants'
objectins to Magistrate Judge's discovery order by Judge
Florence-Marie Cooper (bp) [Entry date 05/23/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/23/02 140 RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following
date(s): 4/23/02 (Re: ) CR: D. Babykin (pjap)
[Entry date 05/29/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/23/02 -- TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 4/23/02 (pjap)
[Entry date 05/29/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 131 REPLY Memorandum by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant
Sonicblue Inc in support of motion for review of Magistrate
Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to
compel responses to docum requests 35 & 44 [93-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/28/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 132 OBJECTIONS filed by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant
Sonicblue Inc to declartion of Craig O. Thomas re: motion
for review of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord
re: dfts cross-motion to compel responses to docum requests
35 & 44 [93-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/28/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 133 REPLY Memorandum by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant
Sonicblue Inc in support of motion for review [86-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/28/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 134 DECLARATION of Jennifer M. Lloyd by defendant ReplayTV Inc,
defendant Sonicblue Inc in support or reply memorandum in
support of motion for review of Magistrate Judge Eick's
04/26/02 discov Ord re: dfts cross-motion to compel
responses to docum requests 35 & 44 [93-1] (bp)
[Entry date 05/28/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 135 DECLARATION of Philippe Rignon, Ph.D., by defendant
ReplayTV Inc, defendant Sonicblue Inc in support of motion
for review of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord
re: dfts cross-motion to compel responses to docum requests
35 & 44 [93-1] (bp) [Entry date 05/28/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 136 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant ReplayTV Inc, defendant
Sonicblue Inc on 5/24/02 of reply memorandum in support of
motion for review of Magistrate Judge's decision. (bp)
[Entry date 05/28/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 137 MEMORANDUM IN RESPONSE by plaintiffs to brief in suppt of
dfts objections to Magistrate Judge's Discovery Order
[93-1] (jp) [Entry date 05/29/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 138 MOTION by plaintiffs to strike portions of and response
to, dfts evidentiary objections to decls submitted in suppt
of plfs motion for review & reconsideration of Magistrate
Judge's discovery Order. (jp) [Entry date 05/29/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/24/02 139 REPLY by plaintiffs in suppt of motion for reconsideration
of Magistrate Judge discov Ord [93-1] (jp)
[Entry date 05/29/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/29/02 143 STIPULATION and PROTECTIVE ORDER by Judge Florence-Marie
Cooper. All "Confidential," "Highly Confidential,"
"Restricted," or "Highly Restricted" information,
hereinafter defined, produced or exchanged in the course of
this litigation, shall be treated in accordance with the
terms of this order and shall be used solely for the
purpose of litigation, arbitration or mediation (see
document for details) (bp) [Entry date 05/31/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/30/02 141 ORDER by Judge Florence-Marie Cooper, taking motion for
review of Magistrate Judge Eick's 04/26/02 discov Ord re:
dfts cross-motion to compel responses to docum requests 35
& 44 [93-1] off calendar. The court has carefully reviewed
all of plaintiffs' objections and arguments concerning the
Magistrate Judge's rulings in each of these categories.
although the arguments made concerning the breadth and
scope of the orders are not unreasonable, and certainly
different orders could have been issued, the unfailing
conclusion reached by this court with respect to each issue
is that the Magistrate Judge's orders are not clearly wrong
or contrary to law. No legal basis exists for this court to
reverse any of the discovery ordes of which plaintiffs
complain (bp) [Entry date 05/31/02] [2:01cv9358]
5/30/02 -- PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED: [Proposed] ORder granting plfs
motion for review & reconsideration of Magistrate Judge's
discovery orders; Lodged 05/10/02 (jp) [Entry date 05/31/02]
[2:01cv9358]
5/31/02 142 MEMORANDUM IN RESPONSE by plaintiffs to brief of AMICI
Curiae Civil Liberties & Consumer Groups (jp)
[Entry date 05/31/02] [2:01cv9358]